NYC’s ritzy Gotham Restaurant victim of $45K cyberscam

  • +5
    B-Edwards
    - Not a phone scam, but still of interest. Less of a difference between Phone/Text and Email scams these days.

    A ritzy Greenwich Village restaurant was forced to close its doors after a $45,000 payroll cyberscam – and now it’s co-owner is warning other businesses to be on the lookout.

    Gotham Restaurant co-owner Bret Csencsitz said they made the difficult choice to shutter temporarily after he was duped into sending the money to a “nefarious actor.”
    “We just couldn’t keep our payroll going, we didn’t have enough money so we’re pausing,” he told The Post in a recent interview.

    The saga started for the upscale eatery on May 10, a Friday, when a thief pretending to work for a company Gotham uses to administer payroll emailed Csencsitz and his human resource staffer to tell them the firm was changing banking information because of “internal issues.”

    The HR staffer contacted Csencsitz to take a look at the request. He combed through past emails and it appeared to be from the employee they typically talk with from the payroll company.

    “And I then wired the money to this new account with the company name and their address,” he said. “It’s not until several hours later we realize something seems a little weird.”
    The scammer had copied the email format that usually comes from the email provider, but after closer inspection – that came too late – the email address had an additional K in the URL, he said.

    “We fell victim to someone who was able to inject themselves into an ongoing dialogue between ourselves and a payroll company,” Csencsitz said.

    “When you look at it you wouldn’t notice it normally,” he added. “But eventually when we’re really digging down into why is this happening we found the difference.”
    He contacted his bank, but so far, the financial institute hasn’t recovered the money. He’s surprised banks don’t do more to safeguard their client’s money. he said.

    Gotham, which offers a New American cuisine, doesn’t have cyber insurance policy, which would have cost a hefty $5,000 annually.
    He has filed a report with the FBI and is in contact with the agency.

    https://nypost.com/2024/06/23/us-news/nycs-ri ... -45k-cyberscam/
  • +4
    BigA
    | 7 replies
    $5,000 policy would have saved him 40 grand.  I doubt that the bank is going to help him since they willingly did whatever it was to transfer the money.
  • +5
    MikeHuntleton replies to BigA
    | 2 replies
    $5,000 a year on Insurance for 9 years would have also cost them $45,000. So doesn't really make much sense to spend that much for a "just incase" when paying attention to your records is much better and cheaper!

    Quote:
    ....to tell them the firm was changing banking information because of “internal issues.”
    That should have been a red flag right there!
    Quote:
    He combed through past emails and it appeared to be from the employee they typically talk with from the payroll company.
    A simple phone call would have saved them, if only they took the time to call instead of sifting through old emails.
  • +5
    B-Edwards replies to MikeHuntleton
    With most payroll services I worked with (albeit years ago) you work with a steady contact person at the service and become familiar with the procedures and reps at the service.
    I was thinking the scammers reached out to the owner hoping they would not be so fast to notice those red flags. Seems like the boss being the boss jumped in to something he should have double-checked with the service and his own staff.

    Scammers love to apply pressure to get fast action and that may have been part of the problem here. The fear of bouncing payroll checks to the staff and maybe the state and feds had to be a factor.
  • +6
    Resident47 replies to BigA
    | 2 replies
    The victim completes a "knowing and willful" transaction with a phantom. The criminal always initiates and sets the scenario which creates the mind-gaming panic. That's not a normal exchange with trusted vendors, it's scheming and manipulation. There's currently debate and compelling argument for leaning on banks to extend their safety nets when business owners get suckered.

    This was aired a month ago in a Senate Homeland Security hearing, with heavy focus on the fraud-plagued bank-owned money zapper Zelle. Witnesses not in favor of blaming victims testified that banks are in the best position to identify fraud patterns and slam some more brakes on threat actors. Banks also have a duty to investigate fraud claims beyond a cursory glance, per the Electronic Funds Transfer Act, a duty which is routinely ignored since it's much simpler to invent reasons why the fraud victim must have "invited" the crisis, almost like Vampire Rules. Bonus points to readers who find this lazy response entirely too similar to what inspires most FCRA lawsuits.

    I won't be accused of coddling the village idiot, but I do think we could all use better guardrails as the career frauds continue to sharpen their game.

    Consumer Advocates Warn of Zelle Scams at Congressional Hearing - CSPAN, 21 May 2024
  • +5
    BigA replies to MikeHuntleton
    Quote:
    $5,000 a year on Insurance for 9 years would have also cost them $45,000. So doesn't really make much sense to spend that much for a "just incase" when paying attention to your records is much better and cheaper!
    True, but we all carry insurance "just incase" don't we?  We have homeowner's or renter's insurance just incase something happens.  We have car insurance again just incase something happens.  Now, while he would have broken even on the $45,000 after paying for 9 years that isn't his only loss.  Now he has to shut down.  He has to scrape up the money to make the payroll and other bills.  He has no income.  His employees are now laid off and they might not come back if he opens up so he would have the expense of finding new employees and training them.  It is a lot more involved than just paying for the insurance and getting the money back.  Yes, he should have been a lot more careful but it seems like they did try to verify the email.  What he didn't do was to call the payroll people up directly which is what should have happened before sending any money.
  • +5
    BigA replies to Resident47
    | 1 reply
    People that use those cash app things should know that their money is at risk but most don't since they are probably mostly young and out of high school/college.  I had a contractor here that wanted me to sign up for one of those services to pay him and I refused.  My money in the bank is guaranteed.  My money in a cash app is not and there are no safe guards on it.  I use a credit or debit card and I can dispute the transaction and the bank will handle it.  I use a cash app and the money is gone with no way to recover it just like using Western Union or handing someone cash.
  • +4
    GregAtTheBeach replies to BigA
    A *lot* of sole proprietorship (small) businesses I deal with now charge an additional 2-3% for credit card transactions, and *no longer accept cash*.  Their preferred transaction method is via so-called "cash apps" like Zelle.  I refuse.

    In the past, they used to include the transaction costs of credit card clearing houses into the cost of doing business with *everybody*.  Not any more.  This effectively penalizes those that pay attention to financial transaction security issues, and behave accordingly, as well as the "elderly" who either can't or won't keep up with the changing web-based financial transaction landscape.
  • -6
    Tyler replies to BigA
    $5,000 a year. So if they were open and paying for this insurance for 8 years it would have cost as much as the scam. It's like buying insurance for blackjack. It really helps if you have blackjack and so does the dealer. But in all the rest of the cases its just a rip-off.

Reply to topic